No amount of technology will make a bad story good
October 07, 2016
When Toy Story opened in the US at the end of 1995, it was met with enthusiasm and great critical acclaim. The film would go on to be the highest-grossing film of the year. There was tremendous buzz (ahem) about the film before it arrived here in Japan a few months later. Much of the talk focused on the stunning 3-D animation and the remarkable technical achievements by Pixar to pull this movie off. I remember sitting in a movie theatre in the spring of 1996 in Osaka, Japan watching the film. I was a bit of a technology geek in those days so what propelled me to actually go see the film initially was the fact that it was the first truly digital animation feature film. And yet the thing that impressed me about the movie was that I soon forgot all about how the animation was created and just remembered being engaged by the story. I wanted to see the film again (and again). I thought it was perfect. Fast forward to today and I have seen every Pixar film ever made dozens of times. I have two small children who adore all the Pixar films and I don't mind watching along with them. If there was a degree given out for watching Pixar films, then I'd by working on my PhD by now.
I watch the films repeatedly because my kids ask to see them, and since our DVDs are in English the movies are more than mere entertainment. But truth be told, I love watching the Pixar films because I have learned so much about story structure, story elements, character, etc. simply by seeing them so many times and paying close attention. These films are designed for adults and kids to enjoy and you may not think there is much to learn from these animated features, but you'd be wrong. Lasseter has said that the first 18 months of working on Toy Story was spent laboring just on the script, that is, the story. The animation is awesome, but it's the story that hooks you, holds you, and rewards you at the end. And it is really, really hard to craft a good one.
There are many lessons from Pixar's prowess at storytelling that we can take and apply to other forms of storytelling, including the 21st-century short-form presentation format. At the end of this documentary on the making of Toy Story, filmed before the film was released, there is a great line by Pixar's now legendary John Lasseter:
"Everyone's going to talk about the fact that this is the very first computer animated feature film, but the computers are just tools [the computers] didn't create this picture, it's the people who created the picture." — John Lasseter
In spite of Pixar's amazing technology, there has always been a focus on the people creating the picture, the people in the audience, and above all, the commitment to the story and the story process.
Steve Jobs on Pixar, Hollywood, and Story
In this 2007 interview of Steve talking with Wall Street Journal columnists Kara Swisher and Walt Mossberg, Jobs tells how the typical live action film will shoot between 10- to one 100-times more footage than will actually appear in the film. After shooting, the film is assembled in editing, which leaves most of what was shot on the cutting room floor. But animation is much too expensive to create a film in this way. Because animation is so expensive you have to edit the film before you actually make it, Jobs explains. This is where storyboarding comes in. The story team has sketches of each scene which follow the progression of the script. A film could have thousands of these.
Putting the story first is one of those things, Jobs said, that's easy to say but hard to do. "Everybody has to make their choice. You find out what people really care about when you are in a tough situation and the meter's running.Then you find out how important they think the story is."
In this short clip from 2009, John Lasseter talks about the importance of storyboarding and creating story reels to see if the story is working or not before starting production on a scene. "We will never let a sequence of a movie go into production until the story reel is working fantastically." If a story reel is working well then Lasseter says it gets a hundred times better once it's animated. "But if a story reel is not working, if the sequence is not working, it will never be improved by all this animation." This is a lesson for all storytellers. It is not about your visuals, and certainly not about the software tools you used to make those visuals. Visuals matter. Visuals are important. But no amount of stunning visualization is going to save a story with a bad design or a presentation that is poorly thought out.
The same is true with video games. No amount of technical wizardry can save a game which has flawed gameplay.
In fact, many game designers will build a board version of their game first to discover or ensure that the basic dynamics of gameplay are enjoyable, because they feel that if the game isn't fun on paper, it won't be fun even after adding all the digital bells and whistles.
Posted by: Perry | April 26, 2014 at 03:22 AM
Hey Garr, I share your affinity for Pixar films. And behind the scenes stuff like this is almost more entertaining to me than their amazing movies.
Have you heard about Pixar-co-founder Ed Catmull's new book, Creativity, Inc? In it he shares lots of goodies like this about how they've managed to create such an amazing environment in which creativity can flourish.
Nancy's book, Slideology, awakened a desire in me to become a presentation designer, but Mr. Catmull's book makes me feel similarly about becoming a manager of a creative team or organization.
Posted by: AdvanceUrSlides | April 28, 2014 at 01:12 PM
Wow - really appreciate how in-depth you got here, looking at the value and importance of the story. So many helpful reminders about the creative process... and that sometimes, you gotta scrap it and start again, because the story is the heart of it all.
Posted by: Sally | May 01, 2014 at 04:48 AM
Great post--the importance of story can never be overemphasized. This reminds me of a great TED talk by another Pixar legend, Andrew Stanton, about the story process and breaking the mold: http://www.ted.com/talks/andrew_stanton_the_clues_to_a_great_story
Posted by: Jennifer | May 03, 2014 at 03:23 AM
Thanks for the Tip about "Creativity, Inc." - that just came out so I missed it. It is GREAT. Got it on Kindle. Highly recommend it. Thanks for the tip.
Also, Ed Catmull has a good talk at The Stanford Business school - it's on Youtube. A dry speaker, but the stories and info are great!
Posted by: garr | May 03, 2014 at 06:42 PM
Thanks Jennifer! Yes that is a good talk. I wrote about it a bit here on this site a couple of years ago:
Thanks again Jennifer. Pixar is a gold mine of advice and inspiration.
Posted by: garr | May 03, 2014 at 06:48 PM